ChatGPT in Education: For cheating or learning?
Lessons learned on using AI to enhance learning rather than inhibit it.
Picture this: A student encounters a challenging math problem. Without hesitation, they turn to ChatGPT, paste the problem, and receive an instant, perfectly formatted solution. Success? Not according to emerging research, which reveals a critical distinction between using AI to enhance learning and using it as a shortcut that can actually inhibit educational growth.
This distinction isn't just theoretical – it's at the heart of how AI will shape the future of education. With teacher familiarity with ChatGPT surging from 25% to 79% in just one year according to a recent Walton Family Foundation survey, educators face a crucial moment. We must decide not just whether to embrace AI in education, but more importantly, how to implement it in ways that truly enhance rather than shortcut the learning process.
The Warning Signs: When AI Inhibits Learning
A recent landmark study from the University of Pennsylvania has shed light on this challenge. Researchers worked with nearly 1,000 Turkish high school students, dividing them into groups to test different approaches to AI-assisted learning. The results were both fascinating and concerning.
Students who had access to a basic GPT-4-powered AI tutor showed dramatic immediate improvements, solving 48% more practice problems correctly. This might sound like a clear win for AI in education – until you look at what happened next. When these same students took tests without AI assistance, they scored 17% worse than their peers who hadn't used the AI tutor at all.
The researchers didn't stop there. They developed a more sophisticated AI tutor designed specifically to provide hints rather than direct answers. While this improved version helped students solve an impressive 127% more practice problems correctly, it still failed to improve actual test performance compared to students who worked without AI assistance.
What's happening here? The researchers concluded that students were using AI as what they termed an "answer machine" – a shortcut to solutions rather than a tool for deeper understanding. It's a pattern that threatens to undermine genuine learning while creating an illusion of progress.
The Path Forward: Enhancing Learning Through AI
But there's another side to this story. While the Penn study highlights the risks, research from Stanford University points toward solutions. Their innovative system, Tutor CoPilot, takes a fundamentally different approach: instead of replacing human instruction, it enhances it.
The Stanford researchers developed Tutor CoPilot to support human tutors, providing them with AI-powered suggestions for teaching strategies, guiding questions, and explanatory approaches. The results were promising: students working with AI-assisted tutors were 4 percentage points more likely to master topics. Even more encouraging, the impact was strongest – a 9 percentage point improvement – for students working with less experienced tutors.
This contrast between the Penn and Stanford studies reveals a crucial insight: AI's impact on learning depends entirely on how we implement it. When used as a replacement for thinking, it inhibits learning. When used to enhance the teaching and learning process, it can amplify educational outcomes.
Practical Strategies for Enhancement, Not Inhibition
For educators looking to ensure AI enhances rather than inhibits learning, here are key principles backed by research:
Focus on Process, Not Just Answers Design assignments that require students to document their thinking process. Instead of "What's the answer?" ask "How would you approach this problem?" and "Why did you choose this method?" This approach makes it harder to simply copy AI outputs and encourages the development of problem-solving skills.
Use AI as a Teaching Assistant, Not a Replacement Follow Stanford's lead by using AI to enhance rather than replace human instruction. Use tools like ChatGPT to generate engaging discussion prompts, create differentiated practice problems, or brainstorm real-world applications of concepts. The key is to maintain the human element while leveraging AI's capabilities.
Teach AI Literacy Alongside Subject Matter Make understanding AI's capabilities and limitations part of the curriculum. Help students recognize that AI can be a powerful learning tool when used thoughtfully, but it's not an infallible oracle. This understanding encourages critical engagement rather than passive acceptance.
The Promise of Balanced Implementation
Recent research from multiple universities offers hope for this balanced approach. A collaborative study involving UCF, Georgia State University, and Morgan State University is exploring AI-enhanced chatbots in foundational courses, with early results showing improved grades and retention rates, particularly among lower-income and first-generation students.
Similarly, the Learning Engineering Virtual Institute has developed specialized tools like the Math Hint Generator Chatbot and Early Literacy Interventions Tool, which provide targeted support while maintaining student engagement in the learning process.
The key to success lies in remembering our goal: to enhance learning, not replace it. When implemented thoughtfully, AI can help create more engaging, effective, and equitable educational experiences. But this requires constant vigilance against the temptation to use AI as a shortcut rather than a scaffold for deeper understanding.
About BrainJoy
BrainJoy is on a mission to equip educators and students with the tools and skills they need to thrive in a rapidly changing, AI-driven world. We provide hands-on AI experiences, classroom-ready lesson plans, and expert resources to help teachers confidently bring the excitement and potential of artificial intelligence to their students.
With Brainjoy, middle and high school STEM teachers can:
Engage students with interactive AI tools that make abstract concepts tangible.
Save time with multi-week AI curricula that integrate seamlessly into existing courses.
Stay ahead of the AI curve with curated articles, guides, and insights from industry experts.
We believe every student deserves the opportunity to explore and understand the technologies shaping their future. That's why we're committed to making AI education accessible, practical, and inspiring for teachers and learners alike.
Ready to bring the power of AI to your classroom? Sign up for a free trial of Brainjoy today and empower your students with the skills of tomorrow.
Visit brainjoy.ai to learn more and get started.